# \<math display\="inline"\>\<mi\>D\</mi\>\</math\>\-meson semileptonic decays to pseudoscalars from four\-flavor lattice QCD

**INSPIRE:** [2618219](https://inspirehep.net/literature/2618219)
**arXiv:** [2212\.12648](https://arxiv.org/abs/2212.12648)
**DOI:** [10\.1103/PhysRevD\.107\.094516](https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.107.094516)

**Authors:** Bazavov, Alexei, DeTar, Carleton, El\-Khadra, Aida X\., Gámiz, Elvira, Gelzer, Zechariah, Gottlieb, Steven, Jay, William I\., Jeong, Hwancheol, Kronfeld, Andreas S\., Li, Ruizi, Lytle, Andrew T\., Mackenzie, Paul B\., Neil, Ethan T\., Primer, Thomas, Simone, James N\., Sugar, Robert L\., Toussaint, Doug, Van de Water, Ruth S\., Vaquero, Alejandro

**Submitted:** 23 December 2022

**Subjects:**
- hep\-lat
- hep\-ph
- Lattice
- Phenomenology\-HEP

**Journal reference:** Phys\.Rev\.D 107 \(9\) 094516 \(2023\)

**Citations:** 64

## Abstract

We present lattice\-QCD calculations of the hadronic form factors for the semileptonic decays \<math display\="inline"\>\<mi\>D\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>π\</mi\>\<mo\>ℓ\</mo\>\<mi\>ν\</mi\>\</math\>, \<math display\="inline"\>\<mi\>D\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>K\</mi\>\<mo\>ℓ\</mo\>\<mi\>ν\</mi\>\</math\>, and \<math display\="inline"\>\<msub\>\<mi\>D\</mi\>\<mi\>s\</mi\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>K\</mi\>\<mo\>ℓ\</mo\>\<mi\>ν\</mi\>\</math\>\. Our calculation uses the highly improved staggered quark \(HISQ\) action for all valence and sea quarks and includes \<math display\="inline"\>\<msub\>\<mi\>N\</mi\>\<mi\>f\</mi\>\</msub\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mn\>2\</mn\>\<mo\>\+\</mo\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\<mo\>\+\</mo\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\</math\> MILC ensembles with lattice spacings ranging from \<math display\="inline"\>\<mi\>a\</mi\>\<mo\>≈\</mo\>\<mn\>0\.12\</mn\>\<mtext\> \</mtext\>\<mtext\> \</mtext\>\<mi\>fm\</mi\>\</math\> down to 0\.042 fm\. At most lattice spacings, an ensemble with physical\-mass light quarks is included\. The HISQ action allows all the quarks to be treated with the same relativistic light\-quark action, allowing for nonperturbative renormalization using partial conservation of the vector current\. We combine our results with experimental measurements of the differential decay rates to determine \<math display\="inline"\>\<msup\>\<mrow\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\<msub\>\<mi\>V\</mi\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>c\</mi\>\<mi\>d\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\</mrow\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>D\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>π\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mn\>0\.2238\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>11\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mtext\>Expt\</mtext\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>15\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mi\>QCD\</mi\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>04\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>EW\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>02\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>SIB\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\[\</mo\>\<mn\>22\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\]\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>QED\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\</mrow\>\</math\> and \<math display\="inline"\>\<msup\>\<mrow\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\<msub\>\<mi\>V\</mi\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>c\</mi\>\<mi\>s\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\</mrow\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>D\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>K\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mspace linebreak\="goodbreak"/\>\<mrow\>\<mn\>0\.9589\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>23\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mtext\>Expt\</mtext\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>40\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mi\>QCD\</mi\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>15\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>EW\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>05\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>SIB\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\[\</mo\>\<mn\>95\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\]\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>QED\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\</mrow\>\</math\>\. This result for \<math display\="inline"\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\<msub\>\<mi\>V\</mi\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>c\</mi\>\<mi\>d\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\</math\> is the most precise to date, with a lattice\-QCD error that is, for the first time for the semileptonic extraction, at the same level as the experimental error\. Using recent measurements from BES III, we also give the first\-ever determination of \<math display\="inline"\>\<msup\>\<mrow\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\<msub\>\<mi\>V\</mi\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>c\</mi\>\<mi\>d\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\</mrow\>\<mrow\>\<msub\>\<mi\>D\</mi\>\<mi\>s\</mi\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>K\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mn\>0\.258\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>15\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mtext\>Expt\</mtext\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>01\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mi\>QCD\</mi\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\[\</mo\>\<mn\>03\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\]\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>QED\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\</mrow\>\</math\> from \<math display\="inline"\>\<mrow\>\<msub\>\<mi\>D\</mi\>\<mi\>s\</mi\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>K\</mi\>\</mrow\>\<mi\>l\</mi\>\<mi\>ν\</mi\>\</math\>\. Our results also furnish new Standard Model calculations of the lepton flavor universality ratios \<math display\="inline"\>\<msubsup\>\<mi\>R\</mi\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>μ\</mi\>\<mo\>/\</mo\>\<mi\>e\</mi\>\</mrow\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>D\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>π\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msubsup\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mn\>0\.98671\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>17\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mi\>QCD\</mi\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\[\</mo\>\<mn\>500\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\]\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>QED\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\</mrow\>\</math\>, \<math display\="inline"\>\<msubsup\>\<mi\>R\</mi\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>μ\</mi\>\<mo\>/\</mo\>\<mi\>e\</mi\>\</mrow\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>D\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>K\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msubsup\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mn\>0\.97606\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>16\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mi\>QCD\</mi\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\[\</mo\>\<mn\>500\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\]\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>QED\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\</mrow\>\</math\>, and \<math display\="inline"\>\<msubsup\>\<mi\>R\</mi\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>μ\</mi\>\<mo\>/\</mo\>\<mi\>e\</mi\>\</mrow\>\<mrow\>\<msub\>\<mi\>D\</mi\>\<mi\>s\</mi\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>K\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msubsup\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mn\>0\.98099\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>10\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mi\>QCD\</mi\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\[\</mo\>\<mn\>500\</mn\>\<msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\]\</mo\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>QED\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\</mrow\>\</math\>, which are consistent within \<math display\="inline"\>\<mn\>2\</mn\>\<mi\>σ\</mi\>\</math\> with experimental measurements\. Our extractions of \<math display\="inline"\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\<msub\>\<mi\>V\</mi\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>c\</mi\>\<mi\>d\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\</math\> and \<math display\="inline"\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\<msub\>\<mi\>V\</mi\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>c\</mi\>\<mi\>s\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\</math\>, when combined with a value for \<math display\="inline"\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\<msub\>\<mi\>V\</mi\>\<mrow\>\<mi\>c\</mi\>\<mi\>b\</mi\>\</mrow\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\|\</mo\>\</math\>, provide the most precise test of second\-row Cabibbo\-Kobayashi\-Maskawa unitarity, finding agreement with unitarity at the level of one standard deviation\.