# \<math display\="inline"\>\<msup\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\<mrow\>\<mo\>\-\</mo\>\<mo\>\+\</mo\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\</math\> hybrid meson in \<math display\="inline"\>\<mi\>J\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>/\</mo\>\<mi\>ψ\</mi\>\</math\> radiative decays from lattice QCD

**INSPIRE:** [2108954](https://inspirehep.net/literature/2108954)
**arXiv:** [2207\.04694](https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.04694)
**DOI:** [10\.1103/PhysRevD\.107\.054511](https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.107.054511)

**Authors:** Chen, Feiyu, Jiang, Xiangyu, Chen, Ying, Gong, Ming, Liu, Zhaofeng, Shi, Chunjiang, Sun, Wei

**Submitted:** 11 July 2022

**Subjects:**
- hep\-lat
- hep\-ex
- hep\-ph
- Lattice
- Phenomenology\-HEP

**Journal reference:** Phys\.Rev\.D 107 \(5\) 054511 \(2023\)

**Citations:** 34

## Abstract

We present the first theoretical prediction of the partial decay width of the process \<math display\="inline"\>\<mi\>J\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>/\</mo\>\<mi\>ψ\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>γ\</mi\>\<msub\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\</msub\>\</math\>, where \<math display\="inline"\>\<msub\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\</msub\>\</math\> is the lightest flavor singlet \<math display\="inline"\>\<msup\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\<mrow\>\<mo\>\-\</mo\>\<mo\>\+\</mo\>\</mrow\>\</msup\>\</math\> hybrid meson\. Our \<math display\="inline"\>\<msub\>\<mi\>N\</mi\>\<mi\>f\</mi\>\</msub\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mn\>2\</mn\>\</math\> lattice QCD calculation at \<math display\="inline"\>\<msub\>\<mi\>m\</mi\>\<mi\>π\</mi\>\</msub\>\<mo\>≈\</mo\>\<mn\>350\</mn\>\<mtext\> \</mtext\>\<mtext\> \</mtext\>\<mi\>MeV\</mi\>\</math\> results in the \<math display\="inline"\>\<msub\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\</msub\>\</math\> mass \<math display\="inline"\>\<msub\>\<mi\>m\</mi\>\<msub\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\</msub\>\</msub\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mn\>2\.23\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>4\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mtext\> \</mtext\>\<mtext\> \</mtext\>\<mi\>GeV\</mi\>\</math\> and the related electromagnetic form factors \<math display\="inline"\>\<msub\>\<mi\>M\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>0\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mo\>\-\</mo\>\<mn\>4\.73\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>74\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mtext\> \</mtext\>\<mtext\> \</mtext\>\<mi\>MeV\</mi\>\</math\>, \<math display\="inline"\>\<msub\>\<mi\>E\</mi\>\<mn\>2\</mn\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>0\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mn\>1\.18\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>22\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mtext\> \</mtext\>\<mtext\> \</mtext\>\<mi\>MeV\</mi\>\</math\>, which give \<math display\="inline"\>\<mi mathvariant\="normal"\>Γ\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mi\>J\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>/\</mo\>\<mi\>ψ\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>γ\</mi\>\<msub\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mn\>2\.04\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>61\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mtext\> \</mtext\>\<mtext\> \</mtext\>\<mi\>eV\</mi\>\</math\>\. These form factors can be applied to the physical \<math display\="inline"\>\<msub\>\<mi\>N\</mi\>\<mi\>f\</mi\>\</msub\>\<mo\>\=\</mo\>\<mn\>3\</mn\>\</math\> case, where there should be two hybrid mass eigenstates \<math display\="inline"\>\<msubsup\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\<mrow\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mi\>l\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\</mrow\>\</msubsup\>\</math\> and \<math display\="inline"\>\<msubsup\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\<mrow\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mi\>h\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\</mrow\>\</msubsup\>\</math\> due to the singlet\-octet mixing\. It is shown that the ratio of the branching fractions \<math display\="inline"\>\<mi\>Br\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mi\>J\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>/\</mo\>\<mi\>ψ\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>γ\</mi\>\<msubsup\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\<mrow\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mi\>l\</mi\>\<mo\>,\</mo\>\<mi\>h\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\</mrow\>\</msubsup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>γ\</mi\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<msup\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mo\>′\</mo\>\</msup\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\</math\> is inversely proportional to the ratio of the total widths of \<math display\="inline"\>\<msubsup\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\<mrow\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mi\>l\</mi\>\<mo\>,\</mo\>\<mi\>h\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\</mrow\>\</msubsup\>\</math\>\. Given our results and the mixing angle derived by a previous lattice study, whether \<math display\="inline"\>\<msub\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>1855\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\</math\> is assigned to be \<math display\="inline"\>\<msubsup\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\<mrow\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\</mrow\>\</msubsup\>\</math\> or \<math display\="inline"\>\<msubsup\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\<mrow\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mi\>h\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\</mrow\>\</msubsup\>\</math\>, the observed branching fraction \<math display\="inline"\>\<mi\>J\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>/\</mo\>\<mi\>ψ\</mi\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<msub\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\</msub\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\(\</mo\>\<mn\>1855\</mn\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>\)\</mo\>\<mo stretchy\="false"\>→\</mo\>\<mi\>γ\</mi\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<msup\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mo\>′\</mo\>\</msup\>\</math\> implies a very large coupling of the octet \<math display\="inline"\>\<msub\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mn\>1\</mn\>\</msub\>\</math\> to \<math display\="inline"\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<msup\>\<mi\>η\</mi\>\<mo\>′\</mo\>\</msup\>\</math\>\. This should be investigated in future studies\.