Comment on "Are two nucleons bound in lattice QCD for heavy quark masses? - Sanity check with Lüscher's finite volume formula -"

INSPIRE: 1601295
arXiv: 1705.09239

Authors: Beane, Silas R., Chang, Emmanuel, Davoudi, Zohreh, Detmold, William, Orginos, Kostas, Parreño, Assumpta, Savage, Martin J., Tiburzi, Brian C., Shanahan, Phiala E., Wagman, Michael L., Winter, Frank

Submitted: 25 May 2017

Subjects:

• hep-lat
• nucl-th
• Lattice
• Theory-Nucl

Citations: 29

Abstract

In this comment, we address a number of erroneous discussions and conclusions presented in a recent preprint by the HALQCD collaboration, arXiv:1703.07210. In particular, we demonstrate that lattice QCD determinations of bound states at quark masses corresponding to a pion mass of $m_\pi = 806$ MeV are robust, and that the phases shifts extracted by the NPLQCD collaboration for these systems pass all of the 'sanity checks' introduced in arXiv:1703.07210.