{ "created": "2014-07-11T00:00:00+00:00", "metadata": { "citation_count": 137, "citation_count_without_self_citations": 120, "publication_info": [ { "year": 2015, "artid": "012001", "journal_issue": "1", "journal_title": "Phys.Rev.Lett.", "journal_record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/journals/1214495" }, "journal_volume": "114" } ], "core": true, "dois": [ { "value": "10.1103/PhysRevLett.114.012001", "source": "bibmatch" } ], "titles": [ { "title": "Hadronic light-by-light scattering contribution to the muon anomalous magnetic moment from lattice QCD", "source": "arXiv" } ], "$schema": "https://inspirehep.net/schemas/records/hep.json", "authors": [ { "uuid": "c982bad4-f40e-42c0-89ee-b8cfafb037f2", "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/authors/1016091" }, "full_name": "Blum, Thomas", "affiliations": [ { "value": "Connecticut U.", "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/institutions/902753" } }, { "value": "RIKEN BNL", "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/institutions/907483" } } ], "signature_block": "BLANt", "curated_relation": true }, { "uuid": "c84cd6f9-b414-455c-bfb8-c533d15e5ce9", "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/authors/2422955" }, "full_name": "Chowdhury, Saumitra", "affiliations": [ { "value": "Connecticut U.", "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/institutions/902753" } } ], "signature_block": "CAWDARYs" }, { "uuid": "28b93b8b-d703-46f2-acad-8ecb223ca494", "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/authors/1006437" }, "full_name": "Hayakawa, Masashi", "affiliations": [ { "value": "Nagoya U.", "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/institutions/903041" } }, { "value": "Nishina Ctr., RIKEN", "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/institutions/911022" } } ], "signature_block": "HYACm" }, { "uuid": "748f7663-d718-459b-9e9e-a991b96f0ae4", "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/authors/1004674" }, "full_name": "Izubuchi, Taku", "affiliations": [ { "value": "Brookhaven", "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/institutions/902689" } }, { "value": "RIKEN BNL", "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/institutions/907483" } } ], "signature_block": "ISABACt" } ], "curated": true, "figures": [ { "key": "bede6ea9dc828762d5a262cf8f67a175", "url": "https://inspirehep.net/files/bede6ea9dc828762d5a262cf8f67a175", "source": "arxiv", "caption": "Hadronic light-by-light scattering contribution to the muon $g-2$, where the grey part consists of quarks and gluons. The wavy lines denote photons, and the dashed arrow line represents the muon.", "filename": "h-LbyL_diagram.png" }, { "key": "2f762f35ae643145723db4b2f1fc6027", "url": "https://inspirehep.net/files/2f762f35ae643145723db4b2f1fc6027", "source": "arxiv", "caption": "Two classes of diagrams contributing to $a_\\mu({\\rm HLbL})$. On the left, all QED vertices lie on a single quark loop, The right diagram is one of six diagrams where QED vertices are distributed over two (or three) quark loops. { We refer to these as (quark) connected and disconnected diagrams, respectively}.", "filename": "hlbl4.png" }, { "key": "349127f61792f007ec14916886afadd4", "url": "https://inspirehep.net/files/349127f61792f007ec14916886afadd4", "source": "arxiv", "caption": "Two classes of diagrams contributing to $a_\\mu({\\rm HLbL})$. On the left, all QED vertices lie on a single quark loop, The right diagram is one of six diagrams where QED vertices are distributed over two (or three) quark loops. { We refer to these as (quark) connected and disconnected diagrams, respectively}.", "filename": "hlbl22.png" }, { "key": "64ddacd6421f3dff3d02f01f8ec8b9b4", "url": "https://inspirehep.net/files/64ddacd6421f3dff3d02f01f8ec8b9b4", "source": "arxiv", "caption": "Perturbative expansion of the first term in Eq.~(\\ref{eq:non pt method}) with respect to QED. The symbols $\\left<,\\,\\right>_{{\\rm QCD} + {\\rm q\\mathchar`-QED}}$ and $\\left<,\\,\\right>_{{\\rm q\\mathchar`-QED}}$ represent the average over QCD$+$QED configurations $(U^{\\rm QCD},\\,A^{\\rm QED})$ and that over $A^{\\rm QED}$, respectively. Terms represented by the ellipsis contain four or more internal photons {and so their orders are higher than $\\alpha^3$}.", "filename": "method_why.png" }, { "key": "a539f6e9b4522b5258c7d2e1ca941bb4", "url": "https://inspirehep.net/files/a539f6e9b4522b5258c7d2e1ca941bb4", "source": "arxiv", "caption": "The muon's magnetic form factor in units of $(\\alpha/\\pi)^{3}$ from light-by-light scattering, evaluated at the lowest non-trivial lattice momentum, $2\\pi/L$. Results for several symmetric source-sink separations are shown; the quark loop is the same for each and corresponds to $m_{\\pi}=329$ MeV (circles). Also shown is the pure QED result (squares, triangle) where the mass of the lepton in the loop is equal to the muon mass, $m_{\\mu}=0.1$. Horizontal lines correspond to continuum QED perturbation theory (upper) and hadronic models~\\cite{Prades:2009tw} (lower). A large excited state contamination is evident for both cases.", "filename": "F2hlbl-tsep.png" }, { "key": "b0c046f84fa4b44c2d788b30ed465d4b", "url": "https://inspirehep.net/files/b0c046f84fa4b44c2d788b30ed465d4b", "source": "arxiv", "caption": "The muon's magnetic form factor in units of $(\\alpha/\\pi)^{3}$ from hadronic light-by-light scattering. $m_{\\pi}=329$ MeV. The time separation between the muon source and sink in this case is $t_{\\rm sep}=10$. The model result (burst) is for physical masses.", "filename": "F2hlbl-qsq.png" } ], "license": [ { "url": "http://arxiv.org/licenses/nonexclusive-distrib/1.0/", "imposing": "arXiv" } ], "texkeys": [ "Blum:2014oka" ], "citeable": true, "imprints": [ { "date": "2015-01-07" } ], "keywords": [ { "value": "13.40.Em", "schema": "PACS" }, { "value": "12.38.-t", "schema": "PACS" }, { "value": "12.20.-m", "schema": "PACS" }, { "value": "12.38.Gc", "schema": "PACS" }, { "value": "muon: magnetic moment", "schema": "INSPIRE" }, { "value": "photon photon: scattering", "schema": "INSPIRE" }, { "value": "muon: mass", "schema": "INSPIRE" }, { "value": "quantum electrodynamics: nonperturbative", "schema": "INSPIRE" }, { "value": "quantum chromodynamics: lattice", "schema": "INSPIRE" }, { "value": "quark: mass dependence", "schema": "INSPIRE" }, { "value": "perturbation theory", "schema": "INSPIRE" }, { "value": "form factor", "schema": "INSPIRE" }, { "value": "numerical calculations", "schema": "INSPIRE" }, { "value": "quark: domain wall", "schema": "INSPIRE" }, { "value": "quark: flavor: 3", "schema": "INSPIRE" } ], "refereed": true, "abstracts": [ { "value": "

The most compelling possibility for a new law of nature beyond the four fundamental forces comprising the standard model of high-energy physics is the discrepancy between measurements and calculations of the muon anomalous magnetic moment. Until now a key part of the calculation, the hadronic light-by-light contribution, has only been accessible from models of QCD, the quantum description of the strong force, whose accuracy at the required level may be questioned. A first principles calculation with systematically improvable errors is needed, along with the upcoming experiments, to decisively settle the matter. For the first time, the form factor that yields the light-by-light scattering contribution to the muon anomalous magnetic moment is computed in such a framework, lattice QCD+QED and QED. A nonperturbative treatment of QED is used and checked against perturbation theory. The hadronic contribution is calculated for unphysical quark and muon masses, and only the diagram with a single quark loop is computed for which statistically significant signals are obtained. Initial results are promising, and the prospect for a complete calculation with physical masses and controlled errors is discussed.

", "source": "APS" }, { "value": "The form factor that yields the light-by-light scattering contribution to the muon anomalous magnetic moment is computed in lattice QCD+QED and QED. A non-perturbative treatment of QED is used and is checked against perturbation theory. The hadronic contribution is calculated for unphysical quark and muon masses, and only the diagram with a single quark loop is computed. Statistically significant signals are obtained. Initial results appear promising, and the prospect for a complete calculation with physical masses and controlled errors is discussed.", "source": "arXiv" } ], "copyright": [ { "year": 2015, "holder": "American Physical Society", "material": "publication" } ], "references": [ { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/710962" }, "reference": { "misc": [ "[Muon G-2 Collaboration]" ], "label": "1", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Bennett, G.W." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "hep-ex/0602035", "publication_info": { "year": 2006, "artid": "072003", "journal_title": "Phys.Rev.D", "journal_volume": "73" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1115845" }, "reference": { "label": "2", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Aoyama, T." }, { "full_name": "Hayakawa, M." }, { "full_name": "Kinoshita, T." }, { "full_name": "Nio, M." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "1205.5370", "publication_info": { "year": 2012, "artid": "111808", "journal_title": "Phys.Rev.Lett.", "journal_volume": "109" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/873506" }, "reference": { "misc": [ "Additional pubnote: Eur.Phys.J.,C72,1874" ], "label": "3", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Davier, M." }, { "full_name": "Hoecker, A." }, { "full_name": "Malaescu, B." }, { "full_name": "Zhang, Z." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "1010.4180", "publication_info": { "year": 2011, "artid": "1515", "page_start": "1515", "journal_title": "Eur.Phys.J.C", "journal_volume": "71" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/900116" }, "reference": { "misc": [ "and T" ], "label": "4", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Hagiwara, K." }, { "full_name": "Liao, R." }, { "full_name": "Martin, A.D." }, { "full_name": "Nomura, D." } ], "imprint": { "publisher": "Teubner" }, "arxiv_eprint": "1105.3149", "publication_info": { "year": 2011, "artid": "085003", "journal_title": "J.Phys.G", "journal_volume": "38" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/604695" }, "reference": { "misc": [ "Additional pubnote: Phys.Rev.,D73,119901" ], "label": "5", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Czarnecki, A." }, { "full_name": "Marciano, W.J." }, { "full_name": "Vainshtein, A." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "hep-ph/0212229", "publication_info": { "year": 2003, "artid": "073006", "journal_title": "Phys.Rev.D", "journal_volume": "67" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1210661" }, "reference": { "misc": [ "and" ], "label": "6", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Blum, T." }, { "full_name": "Hayakawa, M." }, { "full_name": "Izubuchi, T." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "1301.2607", "publication_info": { "year": 2012, "artid": "022", "page_start": "022", "journal_title": "PoS", "journal_volume": "LATTICE2012" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1283181" }, "reference": { "label": "7", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Colangelo, G." }, { "full_name": "Hoferichter, M." }, { "full_name": "Procura, M." }, { "full_name": "Stoffer, P." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "1402.7081" }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/810227" }, "reference": { "misc": [ "(Advanced series on directions in high energy physics. 20) and references therein" ], "label": "8", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Prades, See J." }, { "full_name": "de Rafael, E." }, { "full_name": "Vainshtein, A." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "0901.0306" }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/731201" }, "reference": { "misc": [ "and T" ], "label": "9", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Hagiwara, K." }, { "full_name": "Martin, A.D." }, { "full_name": "Nomura, D." } ], "imprint": { "publisher": "Teubner" }, "arxiv_eprint": "hep-ph/0611102", "publication_info": { "year": 2007, "artid": "173", "page_start": "173", "journal_title": "Phys.Lett.B", "journal_volume": "649" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/691579" }, "reference": { "label": "10", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Hayakawa, M." }, { "full_name": "Blum, T." }, { "full_name": "Izubuchi, T." }, { "full_name": "Yamada, N." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "hep-lat/0509016", "publication_info": { "year": 2006, "artid": "353", "page_start": "353", "journal_title": "PoS", "journal_volume": "LAT2005" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/54871" }, "reference": { "label": "11", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Aldins, J." }, { "full_name": "Kinoshita, T." }, { "full_name": "Brodsky, S.J." }, { "full_name": "Dufner, A.J." } ], "publication_info": { "year": 1969, "artid": "441", "page_start": "441", "journal_title": "Phys.Rev.Lett.", "journal_volume": "23" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/60817" }, "reference": { "misc": [ ";" ], "label": "11", "publication_info": { "year": 1970, "artid": "2378", "page_start": "2378", "journal_title": "Phys.Rev.D", "journal_volume": "1" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/315396" }, "reference": { "label": "12", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Laporta, S." }, { "full_name": "Remiddi, E." } ], "publication_info": { "year": 1991, "artid": "182", "page_start": "182", "journal_title": "Phys.Lett.B", "journal_volume": "265" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/782657" }, "reference": { "misc": [ "[RBC-UKQCD Collaboration]" ], "label": "13", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Allton, C." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "0804.0473", "publication_info": { "year": 2008, "artid": "114509", "journal_title": "Phys.Rev.D", "journal_volume": "78" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/875390" }, "reference": { "misc": [ "[RBC and UKQCD Collaborations]" ], "label": "14", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Aoki, Y." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "1011.0892", "publication_info": { "year": 2011, "artid": "074508", "journal_title": "Phys.Rev.D", "journal_volume": "83" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/415767" }, "reference": { "label": "15", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Duncan, A." }, { "full_name": "Eichten, E." }, { "full_name": "Thacker, H." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "hep-lat/9602005", "publication_info": { "year": 1996, "artid": "3894", "page_start": "3894", "journal_title": "Phys.Rev.Lett.", "journal_volume": "76" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1128469" }, "reference": { "label": "16", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Blum, T." }, { "full_name": "Izubuchi, T." }, { "full_name": "Shintani, E." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "1208.4349", "publication_info": { "year": 2013, "artid": "094503", "journal_title": "Phys.Rev.D", "journal_volume": "88" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1253392" }, "reference": { "label": "17", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Engel, K.T." }, { "full_name": "Ramsey-Musolf, M.J." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "1309.2225" }, "curated_relation": false }, { "reference": { "misc": [ "Private communication with" ], "label": "18", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Bijnens, H." } ] } }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/913590" }, "reference": { "label": "19", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Blum, T." }, { "full_name": "Boyle, P.A." }, { "full_name": "Christ, N.H." }, { "full_name": "Garron, N." }, { "full_name": "Goode, E." }, { "full_name": "Izubuchi, T." }, { "full_name": "Lehner, C." }, { "full_name": "Liu, Q." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "1106.2714", "publication_info": { "year": 2011, "artid": "114503", "journal_title": "Phys.Rev.D", "journal_volume": "84" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1297746" }, "reference": { "label": "20", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Blum, T." }, { "full_name": "Hayakawa, M." }, { "full_name": "Izubuchi, T." } ], "publication_info": { "year": 2013, "artid": "439", "page_start": "439", "journal_title": "PoS", "journal_volume": "LATTICE2013" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1265072" }, "reference": { "label": "21", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Horsley, R." }, { "full_name": "Nakamura, Y." }, { "full_name": "Pleiter, D." }, { "full_name": "Rakow, P.E.L." }, { "full_name": "Schierholz, G." }, { "full_name": "Stben, H." }, { "full_name": "Young, R.D." }, { "full_name": "Zanotti, J.M." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "1311.4554", "publication_info": { "year": 2013, "artid": "499", "page_start": "499", "journal_title": "PoS", "journal_volume": "Lattice2013" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1300659" }, "reference": { "label": "22", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Borsanyi, S." }, { "full_name": "Durr, S." }, { "full_name": "Fodor, Z." }, { "full_name": "Hoelbling, C." }, { "full_name": "Katz, S.D." }, { "full_name": "Krieg, S." }, { "full_name": "Lellouch, L." }, { "full_name": "Lippert, T." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "1406.4088" }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1090734" }, "reference": { "label": "23", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Ishikawa, T." }, { "full_name": "Blum, T." }, { "full_name": "Hayakawa, M." }, { "full_name": "Izubuchi, T." }, { "full_name": "Jung, C." }, { "full_name": "Zhou, R." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "1202.6018", "publication_info": { "year": 2012, "artid": "072002", "journal_title": "Phys.Rev.Lett.", "journal_volume": "109" } }, "curated_relation": false }, { "record": { "$ref": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1202997" }, "reference": { "label": "24", "authors": [ { "full_name": "Lehner, C." } ], "arxiv_eprint": "1211.4013", "publication_info": { "year": 2012, "artid": "126", "page_start": "126", "journal_title": "PoS", "journal_volume": "LATTICE2012" } }, "curated_relation": false } ], "public_notes": [ { "value": "5 pages, 5 figures", "source": "arXiv" } ], "arxiv_eprints": [ { "value": "1407.2923", "categories": [ "hep-lat", "hep-ph" ] } ], "document_type": [ "article" ], "preprint_date": "2014-07-10", "control_number": 1305630, "legacy_version": "20170221142347.0", "number_of_pages": 5, "inspire_categories": [ { "term": "Lattice" }, { "term": "Phenomenology-HEP" }, { "term": "Other" } ], "legacy_creation_date": "2014-07-11", "external_system_identifiers": [ { "value": "1180333", "schema": "OSTI" }, { "value": "2015PhRvL.114a2001B", "schema": "ADS" } ] }, "revision_id": 93, "links": { "bibtex": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1305630?format=bibtex", "latex-eu": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1305630?format=latex-eu", "latex-us": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1305630?format=latex-us", "json": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1305630?format=json", "json-expanded": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1305630?format=json-expanded", "cv": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/1305630?format=cv", "citations": "https://inspirehep.net/api/literature/?q=refersto%3Arecid%3A1305630" }, "uuid": "546fd73e-46c0-4bc0-b614-0c1ecc0da311", "updated": "2024-08-16T16:39:03.437369+00:00", "id": "1305630" }