# Comment on \`Does Gluons Carry Half of the Nucleon Momentum?' by X\.S\. Chen et\. al\. \(PRL103, 062001 \(2009\)\)

**INSPIRE:** [835232](https://inspirehep.net/literature/835232)
**arXiv:** [0910\.5022](https://arxiv.org/abs/0910.5022)
**DOI:** [10\.1103/PhysRevLett\.106\.259101](https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.106.259101)

**Authors:** Ji, Xiangdong

**Submitted:** 2009-10

**Subjects:**
- hep\-ph
- Phenomenology\-HEP

**Journal reference:** Phys\.Rev\.Lett\. 106 259101 \(2011\)

**Citations:** 27

## Abstract

The authors claim to have found a 'proper', 'gauge\-invariant' definition of a charged\-particle's momentum in gauge theory, which is more 'superior' than the textbook version\. I show that their result arises from a misunderstanding of gauge symmetry by generalizing the Coulomb gauge result indiscriminately and is not physical\.