Comment on `Does Gluons Carry Half of the Nucleon Momentum?' by X.S. Chen et. al. (PRL103, 062001 (2009))

INSPIRE: 835232
arXiv: 0910.5022
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.106.259101

Authors: Ji, Xiangdong

Submitted: 2009-10

Subjects:

• hep-ph
• Phenomenology-HEP

Journal reference: Phys.Rev.Lett. 106 259101 (2011)

Citations: 27

Abstract

The authors claim to have found a 'proper', 'gauge-invariant' definition of a charged-particle's momentum in gauge theory, which is more 'superior' than the textbook version. I show that their result arises from a misunderstanding of gauge symmetry by generalizing the Coulomb gauge result indiscriminately and is not physical.